Of the 56 reviews, 17 users gave the Route 211 stop five stars, and 14 gave it four stars.
The American might best be known for its massive portions at a low price, but is also said to have friendly wait staff.
"The calmest most pleasant efficient diner wait staff I've ever met," one customer said. Several others cited their waiters and waitresses by name, saying how pleasant they were.
Breakfast foods and any steak or chicken dish seem to be favorites from the menu, along with freshly-baked desserts like carrot cake and Oreo pie.
The Americana Diner and Restaurant is located at 420 Route 211 West, Middletown.
Click here to follow Daily Voice North Orange and receive free news updates.